Thursday, December 18, 2014

"All One"


Galatians 3.15-29.

I.
            Paul says that the promise God made with Abraham was like a last will that has but one beneficiary, who is the promised Messiah, Jesus Christ.  That promise was made forever, and, like a will, it could not be changed or invalidated by any subsequent agreement.  Since the Law came 430 years later, it does not have the authority to overrule or change the original will or promise.  Therefore, the inheritors of the Promise are not those who keep to the letter of the Law, but Jesus Christ and those who trust in him and are in him.
            The Law came later, mainly “because of offenses,” that is, for the purpose of making it clear when and how people were going astray.   The Law makes visible when we are transgressing.  We only know that something is wrong if there is some kind of law against it. 
            The more positive purpose of the Law was to give structure to the people’s life until the beneficiary, the Messiah, arrived.  The function and purpose of the Law therefore reminds me of several things.
            When I learned to play the trumpet, many, many years ago, I worked through my Dad’s very beat-up and tattered copy of the Arban book, which was then, and I believe still is, the standard manual for learning the trumpet.  The Arban book starts with the most basic elements of trumpet playing, like how to buzz your lips, and proceeds from there with page after page of long and often mind-numbingly boring exercises.  By the time you get to the end of the book, which takes years of practice, you should be a regular Roger Voisin.
            We can extend this analogy to just about anything.  The the grammatical tables and vocabulary lists in a language book; or the calisthenics, drills, and rules involved in learning a sport; or learning to cook by following recipes.  All  of these systems do two things.  They show you how to do the skill right… but they also end up revealing how far short you fall in the process.  They reveal what you’re doing wrong.
            And for any of us who have learned anything like this, it doesn’t take long before we realize that the goal is never fully attained.  The finish-line continually gets pushed farther ahead.  Once you learn the basics, you move on to intermediate and advanced.  But even when we get to the end of the Arban book, we are still not Wynton Marsalis by any stretch.  Simply following the rules doesn’t get us to absolute fluency in a language, it doesn’t make us Michael Jordan, Wayne Gretzky, or Pele. 
            I heard someone on the radio last week describe learning cooking as a girl in Home Ec class and making something for her grandmother, who was from Romania or someplace.  She followed the recipe perfectly, but the grandmother found the dish inedible.  Her comment was, “You killed it with the recipe.”  After being hurt and angry for a time, the girl finally asked what the grandmother meant.  And the grandmother consented to teach her how to cook, a process that began not with learning recipes but with cleaning the kitchen, and then choosing the produce, and only after developing a relationship with the whole process and context, actually cooking something.

II.
            I have been reading since I was about 4 years old.  I read constantly for years.  And I remember how frustrated I was when in like 6th grade, even though I could read and write good sentences, and spelled impeccably, a teacher kept giving me bad grades… because I was not good in identifying the technical parts of speech and grammatical rules.  I’m still not good at that.  I could probably read and write as well as the teacher, but he kept hammering me because I couldn’t tell an adverb from a participle.
            The point of the recipe, or the Arban book, or grammatical rules is to do the task well: to cook a meal, or play the trumpet, or read and write.  If you can get to the goal without all these rules, who cares?  Isn’t the goal the point?
            Paul is saying that the Galatians got to the goal by God’s gift of grace.  They received the Spirit when they heard and took to heart the good news of the crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus.  They have already received, at least in part, the inheritance promised to Abraham’s descendant, the Messiah, Jesus Christ!  In effect they have been given the talent and the skills, which are evident in the results they produce: the love and unity, the forgiveness and acceptance, blessing and joy they share together in their new spiritual community. 
            But now these other teachers show up and tell them that this is not enough.  They have to go back to the recipe, they are told.  They have to go back and start at the beginning of the Arban book.  They have to be able to diagram a sentence.  They have to keep to the letter of the Law of Moses, starting with slicing off part of their bodies. 
            Paul understands that this is insanity.  It would kill the Galatians’ trust in the Lord Jesus if they were forced to learn the rudimentary steps of something that the Spirit is freeing them to accomplish among themselves already.
            Buddhists talk about the difference between the moon and the finger that points to the moon.  If you point to something, a dog will usually express great interest in your finger; it will not usually occur to a dog that your finger is pointing somewhere else and to look over there.  The Galatians had a direct experience of the moon; but their new teachers are trying to get them to concentrate on the finger.  They have the Spirit; but their teachers want them to focus on the Law, the whole purpose of which is to bring people into relationship with… the Spirit.
            It would be like forcing Picasso to do color-by-numbers, or reducing Einstein to doing long-division.

III.
            In the movie, The Matrix, there’s a scene where one of the characters has to fly a helicopter.  So she makes a phone call and simply has the program for flying a helicopter uploaded into her virtual brain.  She did not have to go through years of training.  She does not have to refer to the manual.  She just receives it directly into herself as a kind of gift. 
            Paul is saying that the Galatians received the Spirit kind of like this: directly, by means of their trusting in the faith of Jesus the Messiah, the beneficiary of God’s Promise to Abraham, and seeing their lives re-shaped by the way they lived out this trust together.  Not only is it crazy for them now to imagine that they have to go back and keep the letter of the Law, it is also counterproductive.  It would have the opposite effect.  It would kill their trust in the Lord, and banish the Spirit from their community.
            The miracle is that by God’s grace the gift of faith was bestowed upon these Galatians, without their having to go through the normal sequence of learning the rudimentary rules of the Law and gradually become more proficient with discipline.  They receive the Spirit simply by placing their trust in the message of good news that they heard about how Jesus was crucified by the Romans but defeated them by emerging into a new kind of life. 
            This is why the establishment is so put off by Jesus’ and Paul’s teaching.  First of all, it seems somehow like cheating.  Like in Jesus’ parable where the newcomers in the vineyard get paid the same amount as those who worked in the vineyard all day. 
            Trusting in the faith of Jesus means in effect just sitting and waiting and letting the Lord fill you.  It is a not doing.  It is a response to what the Lord does in and with and among you by the Spirit.  The most you have to do is let your old self die so your true self can be born.  And that is a lot.  You have to give up all the divisions and distinctions that we use to judge and fear other people. 
            And secondly, this approach scares the people in power because it is so dangerous.  It smashes all the ways in which we are held down, or hold each other down; all the ways we cultivate distrust, and the fear, anger, and shame that the powers-that-be use so effectively to keep us enslaved to their agendas and regimes.   If this continues, they reason, as did the High Priest Caiaphas when he encounters Jesus, that it will bring down the wrath of the Empire and destroy everything they hold dear.  Which is absolutely true.
            But when everything we hold dear only serves to enslave us to a corrupt and violent order, its passing is not a bad thing.  It is in fact a liberating event, and we emerge on the other side of it unscathed because of our trust in the resurrection of Jesus Christ.

IV.            
            But in the end, by trusting in Jesus Christ, we do keep the Law, in Spirit.  We can actually do what the Law requires, which is justice, righteousness, and love.  But like with an accomplished artist or poet, this happens not according to the written rules, but beyond the rules.  The rules – the recipe, the scales, the grammar, the calisthenics – actually hold you back at this point.  Now we look at the fruits, the effects, the results, the kind of life that is produced by trusting in Jesus.
            This is something the church has not been willing to look at very much because we have been such a colossal failure here.  Coming to church is supposed to make us better people.  Yet far too many people go regularly to church for decades and remain just as bad if not worse than they were when they were confirmed as adolescents.  They are still dominated by fear, anger, and shame.  Many people remain at least as violent, resentful, hateful, nasty, small-minded, and bitter as before.  Many even find ways to twist and debase the good news of Jesus to rationalize and inflate their own greed, bigotry, cowardice, and narrow-mindedness.
            Churches need to look carefully at what kind of community and people we are fostering.  That will tell us whether we are really hearing and trusting in the good news of Jesus Christ.  That will tell us whether the Spirit is with us or not. 
            Are we living together according to Paul’s magnificent statement in 3:28, which I have been repeating on most Sunday mornings when I fill the font?  “For as many of you as have been baptized into Christ have clothed yourselves with Christ.  There is now no longer Jew or Greek, slave or free, male and female, for all of you are one in Christ Jesus.”  Scholars believe Paul is quoting an early hymn of the Jesus-movement, something the Galatians would have recognized.  It is one of the essential key verses in the New Testament.
            It means that God’s action in Jesus Christ, in his crucifixion and resurrection, has fundamentally changed human life and fulfilled God’s original promise to Abraham.  It means that in him all have been made one, a truth in which we participate and which we proclaim in our baptism.  Our baptism washes away all our superficial differences that we make to be so important, and reveals at our heart and core an essential oneness, in the flesh we share with the Lord Jesus, and therefore with God.   In our baptism our old self symbolically dies and our new self in Christ, our deepest, truest, and most original self, emerges into our conscious life.
            It means no one is an alien, an enemy, a competitor, a rival, and the divisions upon which the Romans depended to keep us broken and under their control, no longer exist.  They never really existed at all.  They were an illusion produced by our egos to keep us enslaved to fear and violence.

V.
            In Jesus Christ we are witnesses to a unity that is true, but that has not yet been realized in human society, which still languishes in falsehood.  This unity, in which all barriers of separation have been broken down, is the Promise that God gave to Abraham.  That in his descendant, Jesus, all nations would be blessed.  The land that his heirs, those who trust in Jesus Christ, the beneficiary of his Promise, inherit is not just a sliver of real estate in the middle-east; it is the whole planet, all creation, all nations, the whole world.  As Jesus says in John 4, the Promise is not about this or that mountain or temple, but about worshiping everywhere in Spirit and in truth.
            This is a truth that we demonstrate and proclaim by the love, peace, and justice that characterizes our life together in the gathering of disciples, and our outward life, projected and expressed in our engagement with and in God’s creation and people.  It means that not only have the barriers been dissolved in our own gathering; but also we work hard to reveal that the barriers have been vaporized everywhere.
            For now there is no longer Jew or Greek, slave or free, male and female… Gay or straight, native and alien, Black or white, rich or poor, Christian or Muslim or Jew or Buddhist or Hindu, for all are one in Christ Jesus.  All are one in God.  All are one in goodness, blessing, hope, joy, and love.
+++++++ 

Receiving the Spirit.


Galatians 3:1-14.

I.
            Paul says that the indicator of the authentic good news of Jesus is the reception of the Holy Spirit.  That’s how we know if we are getting the real good news or not.  Do we receive the Holy Spirit? 
            How well do we measure up to this standard?  If the only authentic worship is that in which people receive the Spirit, what does that mean for us?  Are we receiving the Spirit?  What does it mean to receive the Spirit anyway?
            Some of our Pentecostal sisters and brothers have very specific experiences which indicate the reception of the Spirit, like speaking in tongues.  I have great respect for the Pentecostal movement.  It is the fastest growing part of Christianity all over the world.  Yet, I am not totally convinced that what Paul means by receiving the Spirit can be reduced to just those kinds of experiences.  He certainly is not that explicit here in Galatians.
            At the same time, it is clear that Paul is talking about something remarkable, amazing, miraculous, unusual, and powerful.  Receiving the Spirit is not part of our normal experience.  It is a break with what we are used to and what we expect.  It can’t be explained away as something normal.
            Paul says that receiving the Spirit happens to the Galatians because they trusted in the good news they were hearing, centered around the death by crucifixion of Jesus Christ, and his subsequent resurrection. 
            So the good news is that a Jewish man named Jesus, whom the Romans executed for sedition, which is basically the only reason anyone got crucified, rose from the dead.  That means that he defeated Rome by neutralizing their most effective means of inspiring terror in conquered peoples.  Rome’s agenda of violence, exploitation, extraction, subjugation, and humiliation is now defunct.  We do not have to live in fear or disunity anymore.  And to trust, or believe, in this good news means to live going forward without fear, without the other values Rome pushes: like greed, anger, hatred, shame, or  inequality.
            Because of what God does in Jesus Christ, we all – even Gentiles – are free.  We are free to realize hope, peace, love, sharing, unity, generosity, and equality in our life together.  We are free to form new communities where these values are lived and expressed and shared.
            And more even than this, we are free from the demonic spiritual forces Rome represents, forces which have the whole creation in bondage and terror, forces which have bound and enslaved even the human soul.  Jesus Christ didn’t just die and rise again to defeat someone as inconsequential as Caesar; he defeated every evil power in the universe that tries to dominate people by making them enemies of each other and of their true selves.

II.
            Paul says that Jesus Christ finally fulfills the promise God makes to Abraham in Genesis 12, that all the nations would be blessed in him.  This promise is not just for one particular nation, but for everyone.  It is, furthermore, not just for people who keep to the letter of the Jewish Law.  It is for everyone.
            Paul stops trusting in Jewish exceptionalism and legalism when Jesus, he says, appears in, or to, him.  That experience causes him to realize three things. 
            First, his nation is really no different from any other nation; they are just another name on the list of conquered peoples.  There is no appreciable difference between Jew and Gentile in this respect.  All are united in their subjugation by Rome.
            Secondly, Jesus’ resurrection after he was crucified defeats Rome, not just on behalf of Jews, but for everyone.  Therefore, the people of every nation on that list of conquered peoples are liberated in Jesus Christ.  In fact, Christ liberates the whole creation from bondage to sin and evil, and therefore it is the best news ever and needs to be proclaimed far and wide.  All people may participate in this liberation by placing their wholehearted trust in Jesus Christ and his saving act.
            Finally, he realizes that the Law, for which he had been so zealous when he saw it to be the centerpiece of his Jewish faith, is utterly irrelevant to this new thing that God has done.  In fact, it is worse than irrelevant.  The Law has been turned into a barrier to faith and now works against this liberation from the power of Rome and cosmic evil.  What God is doing now is actually against the letter of the Law, because according to the Law Jesus is cursed because he was crucified.
            Furthermore, because of the deal made with the Romans by which Jews were exempted from having to worship the Emperor, keeping the Law is now no longer a brave statement of resistance to evil and injustice.  It is not, as originally intended, a way to reject the values of Pharaoh and live a new, free life as equals in God’s sight.  It is not an act of courage to keep the Law, as it was during the exile in Babylon.  Now the Law is a cynical, backhanded statement of allegiance to the Emperor, by which Jews accept from him a special status, different from all other peoples.  Now the Law makes Jews little more than the Emperor’s pets who owe their life not to God but to the Emperor.

III.
            The artificial distinction between Jews and Gentiles cuts against the truth of the good news of God’s redeeming, liberating, inclusive love for all, revealed and accomplished by Jesus Christ in his crucifixion and resurrection.  So when some Jewish followers of Jesus come to Galatia and start preaching that the if the new Gentile disciples there want follow Jesus the right way they have to become Jewish and keep the Law, beginning with undergoing the ritual of circumcision, Paul goes ballistic.
            They based their argument on Abraham, who receives circumcision as a sign of God’s promise and covenant.  Paul’s rejoinder is that Abraham’s circumcision came after he had already been made righteous by God on account of his trusting in God’s promise.  It is therefore those who place their trust in God like Abraham did who are the true spiritual descendants of Abraham. 
            Paul says, “All those who rely on the works of the Law are under a curse, because it is written, ‘Everyone is cursed who does not keep on doing all the things that have been written in the Law scroll.’”  Paul’s argument is not that it is impossible to keep the Law perfectly.  That may be so.  But his point is that keeping the Law does not liberate someone from the hegemony of evil, executed by Rome.  Someone who is liberated and therefore accepted by God as righteous and just, is the one who lives by trusting in God’s promise, fulfilled in Jesus Christ. 
            The Law is not about trust.  It can even be about abdicating one’s trust in God by reducing trust and faithfulness to a mere adherence to rules and regulations, something that can be interpreted in a very self-serving way.  Obeying the Law is something a person does; but to trust in God hands the initiative over to God.
            Paul sums it up in verses 13 and 14.  “Christ redeemed us from the curse of the Law by becoming a curse for us – because it is written, ‘Everyone who is hung on a tree is cursed.’”  Christ draws on himself crucifixion, the Roman punishment for sedition and something the Jewish Law says brings a curse.  In so doing he demonstrates that Judaism and Rome are on the same side; because both are united in their hostility and violence towards him, God’s anointed One.  He shows that Roman Law and Jewish Law are basically the same.  Christ takes on himself the curse of both, and he dies a gruesome, lonely death on account of both.
             By thus breaking down the difference between Jewish and Roman Law, and identifying with all the people who had been victimized unjustly by Rome, Paul says that Christ wiped out our differences, so that the blessing of Abraham could come to the Gentiles through him.  And we would receive the promise of the Spirit by trusting in Christ’s action.

IV.
            It was trusting in God, by means of hearing and embracing the story of Jesus’ crucifixion and resurrection, that opened their hearts to the Holy Spirit.  Why, having already received the Spirit, would the Galatians in effect go backwards, and start doing something that not only doesn’t bring the Spirit but could actually cut them off from the Spirit?
            Well, I know why.  Receiving the Spirit is a very dangerous thing.  It puts you in jeopardy.  It can make you a curse, and cursed, by people.  In the case of the Galatians, it put their lives on the line with the Roman State.  Receiving the Spirit changes everything, and some folks are afraid of that change.
            For 2,000 years, the church has tried to at all costs to avoid receiving the Spirit.  Theologically, the doctrine of the Holy Spirit has been woefully neglected.  In worship, the Holy Spirit gets dutiful mention in the Gloria, and almost never again.  Presbyterians are notorious for taking great pains to ensure that nothing out of control happen in worship.  And the Spirit is always by nature out of control.
            And I am not talking about the visible things like waving our hands or moving our bodies, though that can be part of it.  I am talking about the out-of-controlness of a worship that breaks down barriers, and reaches out to include many different kinds of people, and unites us all as equals before God and therefore with each other.  I am talking about worship that says an emphatic “No” to the forces within us and outside of us that want us to hate, fear, be angry, be ashamed, and be otherwise at enmity with each other and with God.
             That is the miracle that Paul saw happening with the Galatians; that is what receiving the Spirit meant to them.  He saw things happening among them that people simply cannot just do on their own.  He saw things that only the Spirit of God can do.  He saw differences dissolve, he saw people accept and embrace and forgive each other, he saw rich and poor, men and women, sick and well, young and old, locals and strangers, learn to love each other with honesty and openness.  He saw people willingly and joyfully decide that they would not worship the Emperor no matter what the punishment.  Because Christ showed them that the Emperor really has no power over them.  He can only kill their bodies.  But he can’t kill the new life they have together in the Spirit.

V.
            That kind of life together will always be subversive.  Because the Roman Empire and its values of exploitation, inequality, domination, violence, fear, greed, and division never really ended.  It was the expression at that time of the principalities and powers of evil that have held humans and human societies, and therefore all creation, in their oppressive grip for about as long as people have been around.  Rome just represents whoever our owners and masters are in any age.  It is the corrupted power of leaders, the wealthy, the powerful, the smart, the strong, and any who make themselves like god to someone else by claiming power over them.
            And we know the Presence and power of God’s Holy Spirit when we don’t see any of that among us.  What we see instead is gentleness and humility, patience and acceptance, forgiveness and forebearance, open-heartedness and open-mindedness, honesty and directness, and an inclusive sense that we are all equal and precious in the sight of God, and therefore in the sight of each other.  What we see then is joy and peace. 
            Where we trust in the Spirit, and in the Word of God, Jesus Christ, who pours the love of God into our hearts, that is where the Spirit appears.  Where we are willing to let everything go: pride, tradition, habit, desire, money, job, family, religion – that’s when the Spirit shows up.  And the Spirit gives us back many of these things and relationships in new, shining, colorful, vibrant, and living forms. 
            But we have to trust in the Spirit.  And that means realizing that it’s never going to be like it was… and that is a very good thing.
+++++++